[hist-analytic] A. G. N. Flew (1923-2010)
Jlsperanza at aol.com
Jlsperanza at aol.com
Wed Apr 14 00:18:33 EDT 2010
S. R. Bayne subscribes to PHILOS-L and CHORA and so he must have heard from
R. Lewis that the Daily Telegraph had telephoned him vis a vis the short
obit. in "The Times" of yesterday, re: the passing of A. G. N. Flew. I have
commented a bit on his work elsewhere. There is so much to discuss about
this genius. Perhaps list-members to Bayne's list can contribute.
I particularly treasure his two series for Blackwell, "Logic and Language".
He was tuteed by Grice at St. John's where he was a Casberd Scholar, and
through which he obtained, like Grice had, a first in Lit. Hum. After a
short sojourn as Student of Christ Church, he left Oxford for good in September
1950, which was a big blow for Oxonian analysis.
I think the deah of Ordinary Language Philosophy was provoked, though, by
two main dates:
---- the death of J. L. Austin in 1960.
---- the departure of H. P. Grice for the USA in 1968.
---- Flew argued over many things ("Inflewenza" and "One Flew Over the
Cuckoo's Nest" could be titles for Flewian analysis -- etc.). In a footnote to
"Philosophy and Language" he makes a passing comment where he describes
Humpty-Dumpty (who he must have known well from his Christ Church days) as an
'anarchist'! if you can believe that. I was lucky to have presented to the
Lewis Carroll Society, of Luton, Beds, a paper which I entitled
"Conversational Impenetrability" (and was published in the Society's Journal,
"Jabberwocky")where I labour the point. Of course Flew is wrong. As D. F. Pears
and, indeed, Davidson in the PGRICE festschrift (Grandy/Warner) point out,
Humpty Dumpty was NOT such thing. As he politely notes to Alice (upon her
naive, "I didn't know what you mean by 'glory'"), "Of course you don't until I
tell you". So, the 'intention' on the part of the egg is such that his
addressee WILL recognise the intention: yes, a Gricean echo! -- Borrowing from
Locke (another Christ Churchian, like Flew, and Pears) I re-label the egg a
'semantic' libertarian, rather. Well, at least he was not a 'semantic
communist' (those who endorse the view that the institution called "Language"
has primacy over its speakers and imposes its 'meaning-intentions' on them!).
J. L. Speranza
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the hist-analytic