### Aristotle - The Organon ANALYTICA PRIORIA Book 2 Part 19

## Do not allow the same term twice in premisses

1.
In order to avoid having a syllogism drawn against us we must take
care, whenever an opponent asks us to admit the reason without the
conclusions, not to grant him the same term twice over in his
premisses, since we know that a syllogism cannot be drawn without a
middle term, and that term which is stated more than once is the
middle.
How we ought to watch the middle in reference to each
conclusion, is evident from our knowing what kind of thesis is
proved in each figure. This will not escape us since we know how we
are maintaining the argument.

2.
That which we urge men to beware of in their admissions, they
ought in attack to try to conceal.
This will be possible first, if,
instead of drawing the conclusions of preliminary syllogisms, they
take the necessary premisses and leave the conclusions in the dark;
secondly if instead of inviting assent to propositions which are
closely connected they take as far as possible those that are not
connected by middle terms. For example suppose that A is to be
inferred to be true of F, B, C, D, and E being middle terms.
One ought
then to ask whether A belongs to B, and next whether D belongs to E,
instead of asking whether B belongs to C; after that he may ask
whether B belongs to C, and so on.
If the syllogism is drawn through
one middle term, he ought to begin with that: in this way he
will most
likely deceive his opponent.

HTML edition © created 1996/11/25 modified 2009/04/26